PSA: My media buyer friend said to kill our broad match campaigns, and our CPA dropped $14 in 3 weeks
Six months ago I was running broad match on almost everything because a course I paid $500 for said it was the way to scale. My friend Dana, who buys ads for a furniture store in Dallas, sat down with me and said "broad match is bleeding you dry, pull the budget and put it on phrase instead." I pushed back hard because broad was giving us way more volume. She asked me to run one campaign split for 21 days, so I did, and the phrase side came in at a $31 CPA while broad sat at $45. That was with about $2,800 in spend across both, so it wasn't a tiny sample. I moved the rest of the budget over and our cost per signup settled around $29 by the end of the month. Dana gets to say I told you so at every cookout now. Has anyone else seen broad match fall apart like this on smaller budgets, or did I just have a bad setup?