Warning: I was judging banned ads by the wrong thing for 2 years
I used to rate every pulled ad in here by shock value alone, and last Tuesday I finally clocked why my picks kept losing in the comments. Someone posted that 2011 Skittles spot where the guy kisses a giraffe and I gave it a 9, but a mod in Grand Rapids replied that half these ads got pulled for legal clearance issues, not because they were wild. So I went back through 40 of my old votes and sure enough, the ones folks actually loved were the dumb simple ones like the Puppy Monkey Baby, not the gross-out stuff. Now I check why an ad got yanked before I score it. How do you all weigh shock against actual weirdness when you rate these?