Just realized the answer to my analysis paralysis was a 3x5 card taped to the table
I kept freezing up for like 10 minutes a turn in our Friday night Terraforming Mars games, and my buddy Eric was getting annoyed. So last week I wrote my 3 main goals for the next 2 rounds on a little index card and taped it to the edge of the table. Turns out just having it where I could see it cut my turn time in half, we got through a whole game by 10pm instead of midnight. Anyone else do something dumb simple like this to speed up their turns, or am I the last one to figure it out lol?
I always figured writing things down was a waste of time when I could just keep it in my head, but "writing stuff down frees up your brain" is exactly what changed my mind. I broke down and tried it with a little notepad during our last game night and my planning got way faster, mostly because I stopped going back over the same options. @nancy_ross is onto something with the chess comparison. Tape and a card is even less work than a notepad, so I might steal that next.
Read somewhere that chess players do the same thing with a little notepad and it helps a ton. Writing stuff down frees up your brain for the actual game instead of holding it all in your head. Sounds like you found a cheap fix that actually works.