c/baking-fails-and-wins

Took me 4 years to figure out why my sourdough was always flat

I started baking sourdough back in 2021 like everyone else during lockdown. My loaves kept coming out dense and flat no matter what recipe I tried. I switched flours, messed with hydration, bought a fancy proofing basket, all that stuff. Turns out my tap water in Phoenix was too chlorinated and it was killing the yeast activity. I finally switched to filtered water last month and the difference was night and day. First bake after that had a huge oven spring and I nearly cried. Has anyone else fought with water chemistry for way too long before figuring it out?

0 comments

julia557•11d ago

Warning: My $280 silicone bread mats melted into my loaves

I bought a set of those fancy non-stick silicone bread mats last spring, thought I was being smart. First few bakes were fine, then one day I pulled a sourdough out at 475 and the bottom had these weird black streaks. Turns out the cheap ones start breaking down at high temps. Checked the package after, it said good to 500, total lie. Had to toss the loaf and scrub my stone for an hour. Anyone else had silicone gear fail on them or am I the only fool who trusted the label?

0 comments

felix_lane99•11d ago

Sourdough starter math finally clicked after 14 days of feeding

I kept seeing vague ratios online but never understood why my starter doubled then collapsed every single time. Then I read King Arthur's guide that said 1:2:2 feeding at 78 degrees means the starter peaks around 6 hours, not whenever you remember to check it. I set a timer for once and actually caught the rise, my bread came out 40% taller than any loaf before. Has anyone else tracked their peak time and found it shifts way more than the recipes claim?

0 comments

jakel36•14d ago

My $90 proofing box never got above 70 degrees

I ordered a cheap proofing box off a random website last month, and it showed up with a dead heating element inside. I lost $90 on the thing plus two batches of sourdough that never rose. The box warmed up to around 70 degrees and just sat there, useless. Has anyone else had luck with a cheaper alternative, or should I just stick to the oven with a pan of hot water?

0 comments

henderson.vera•15d ago

Saw a tip about chilling cookie dough overnight and it actually fixed my spread problem

I read a random comment on a recipe site saying to chill dough for at least 12 hours before baking. I always skipped that because I wanted cookies right then lol. Finally tried it with a batch this past Saturday and my cookies came out thick and soft instead of flat pancakes. The flavor was deeper too. Has anyone else noticed a huge difference with overnight chilling or is it just this recipe? I used my usual chocolate chip recipe, nothing fancy, in my tiny 1990s oven in Tampa.

0 comments

miam75•15d ago

The Great Butter Explosion of Last Tuesday

Put a cold stick of butter in a warm oven to soften it for 5 minutes, walked away to feed the cat, and came back to a molten lake all over the heating element, so please learn from my $30 mess and just use the microwave at 10 second bursts like a sane person.

0 comments

julia557•16d ago

My aunt said to tap the pan twice. I laughed. Now I get it.

She's been baking pies since the 80s and told me to tap the filled pie pan twice before the oven. I thought it was some old wives tale. Last week I forgot to do it and ended up with a giant air pocket under my apple filling. Took 3 tries to figure out what went wrong after I re-read her note. Has anyone else had a tiny step like that save a whole bake?

1 comments

terry_carter15•17d ago

My sourdough starter survived a 2 week power outage, somehow

Lost power for 14 days during that ice storm in Portland last winter. I figured the starter was done for, but I threw it in a cooler with a couple of warm water bottles and forgot about it. When the lights came back, it had a hooch layer an inch deep but perked right up after one feeding. Anybody else had a starter bounce back from a worse situation, or did I just get lucky with the cold temps?}

0 comments

tara_jones94•17d ago

Frosting texture debate: my aunt's buttercream rant still bugs me 8 months later

At my cousin's wedding shower in Cleveland last spring, my aunt took one bite of the vanilla cake and announced, "This frosting is too stiff, real buttercream should melt on your tongue in 3 seconds." I'd spent 2 hours whipping that Swiss meringue at 78 degrees, and she wouldn't even try the chocolate layer. Now I'm torn between her old-school shortening recipe and my stabilized version that holds up in heat. So which side are you on: soft and melty, or firm enough to pipe a sharp edge? Has anyone else had a relative trash their frosting and then secretly copy your method later?

1 comments

the_nina•17d ago

My sister said my bread was 'too pretty to be tasty' and she was right

I spent 3 years obsessing over scoring and oven spring, then one taste of a dense ugly loaf from a bakery in Portland showed me what I was missing. Anyone else get humbled by someone who thinks fancy equals flavorless?

1 comments

willow114•18d ago

My sourdough went from frisbee to bakery in 4 months

I kept making loaves that were flat and dense, like actual doorstops. Then I started tracking my bulk fermentation time and dough temp with a cheap probe thermometer. Turns out my kitchen was 10 degrees colder than the recipe assumed, so I was underproofing by like 3 hours every time. Now I wait until the dough jiggles and has those big bubbles on top, total game changer. Has anyone else had a specific variable that fixed their bread after months of fails?

1 comments

wesley_martin•19d ago

My sourdough starter kept failing at 4 weeks, turns out the tap water was the problem

I tried for a month on the same counter, same flour, same feeding schedule. Every morning it would bubble a little then die out by night. My neighbor swore her starter loved our city water. I switched to bottled water for 5 days and it tripled in size. I looked it up later, our town adds extra chlorine in summer. Has anyone else had a hidden water issue that took forever to pin down?

1 comments

hugoh55•21d ago

My Bundt cake stuck so bad it took the pan's nonstick coating with it

Last Sunday I greased and floured that pan like always, but the cake split in half and tore the coating right off the bottom, now it's just bare metal... Has anyone else lost a pan to a stubborn cake?

1 comments

hernandez.finley•21d ago

Overheard my neighbor say 'baking is just chemistry with butter' and it clicked

I was outside last Tuesday and my neighbor, who owns a bakery in Portland, was telling someone that baking is just chemistry with butter. I always thought my failed sourdough was bad luck, but she pointed out that my kitchen was too cold and my starter needed feeding 8 hours earlier. So I tried again, wrote down the room temp and exact feeding time on my phone, and the loaf actually rose for the first time in 5 attempts. Do you guys track your proofing conditions or do you just wing it and hope for the best?

0 comments

fox.derek•22d ago

Spent $46 on a custom bundt pan that fell apart after 2 uses

The fancy nonstick coating started peeling right after the second bake, and my lemon pound cake came out looking like a crime scene. Anyone else had luck with those silicone pans instead, or should I just stick to my old metal one?

1 comments

jenniferw82•23d ago

Frosting crisis at my sister's baby shower last Saturday

I was making a three layer vanilla cake and my buttercream split right in the middle of piping. The kitchen in my apartment hit 85 degrees and the butter just gave up. Instead of tossing it, I chilled the bowl for 10 minutes, then rewhipped it on low speed with a splash of heavy cream. It came back smooth enough to finish the cake. Has anyone else saved a broken frosting this way, or do you just start over?

1 comments

umathompson•24d ago

Question about the science behind cold butter in pie dough

Tbh I read somewhere that the ideal temp for butter in pie dough is around 55 degrees F, not just 'cold from the fridge'. It said if it's too hard it won't create those flaky layers properly. I tried it this weekend with my morning recipe and the crust actually looked way better, but I'm wondering if I was just lucky. Does anyone actually check the butter temp with a thermometer or is that overkill? Has anyone else seen this tip and had mixed results?

1 comments

maryt62•24d ago

My sister's one comment about my cake layers fixed my frosting game

I always struggled with cakes sliding apart when I frosted them. My sister watched me one time and said, 'you're putting warm frosting on warm cake, of course it melts.' She was right, I was rushing straight from the oven to the stand mixer. Now I chill each cake layer in the freezer for 20 minutes and let the buttercream sit at room temp for 10 before spreading. First cake after that stayed together perfectly, no sliding at all. Has anyone else had a family member point out something that obvious that you just couldn't see?

1 comments

the_patricia•25d ago

A stranger's 3-word comment made me stop over-proofing my sourdough

Tbh I always thought longer proofing meant better flavor, so I'd push it 12 hours on the counter every time. Last Saturday a guy at the farmers market took one bite of my loaf and said "too tangy, airy." I switched to a 4 hour bulk ferment plus overnight fridge rest, and the crumb is way more even, first real change in 2 years. Anyone else get random criticism that actually fixed their process?

1 comments

margaret_gonzalez25•29d ago

Left the butter out overnight and it actually worked out

Last Tuesday I forgot to soften butter for a birthday cake and just left it on the counter overnight by accident. I woke up at 6am stressed, but it was perfectly soft and the cake came out so fluffy. Now I'm wondering if I should always plan ahead like this or if it's just asking for trouble in the summer heat. Has anyone else tested the overnight butter method with success or horror stories?

1 comments

andrew_rodriguez•1mo ago

Beware the baking soda swap, ruined my whole sourdough batch

Last Thursday I grabbed the box from my pantry without checking and used baking soda instead of powder in my morning loaf, it came out flat and bitter and now I double-check every container before it goes in, has anyone else done this with a similar outcome?

1 comments

hunt.quinn•1mo ago

My sourdough starter exploded in the fridge last night

I fed it on Monday and forgot to burp the jar before I left for work, came home to dough splattered all over the shelf and a cracked lid. Took me 2 hours to scrub the inside of my fridge with vinegar, and I lost most of the starter since it dried out. Anyone else have a routine to avoid this or should I just switch to a bigger container?

2 comments

evaallen•1mo ago

Spent 2 hours trying to fix a simple cookie recipe that kept spreading flat

Turns out my butter was too soft from sitting out all day in the summer heat. Took me three failed batches to figure out it was 85 degrees in my kitchen. Has anyone else had a simple ingredient temp problem ruin a whole afternoon?

2 comments

jakel36•1mo ago

Just wrecked my sourdough starter on a camping trip last month

I was up in the Sierras at a campsite near Bishop and forgot my starter in the cooler overnight. Next morning it had this weird pinkish layer on top and smelled like acetone. Tried to feed it back to life but after 3 days of no bubbles I had to toss it. My buddy who bakes said I probably got cross contamination from a dirty spoon. I'm starting a new batch now but it feels like losing a pet honestly. Has anyone saved a starter after something like this happened to them?

2 comments

johnson.jason•1mo ago

My aunt called my sourdough starter a science experiment last week

She meant it as a joke but it got me thinking about how much I focus on ratios and temperatures instead of just enjoying the process. Has anyone else had family say something that made you second guess your baking?

2 comments